I am writing to file an official complaint regarding what I see as misleading comment by your employee, Dr. Gary Marty, to the public in the Globe and Mail today.
In this article: http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/british-columbia/disease-killing-pacific-herring-threatens-salmon-scientist-warns/article13722113/
Dr. Marty is quoted suggesting that a limited VHS outbreak could be “actually good…” for herring populations in BC.
While Dr. Marty appears to be quoting scientific research, he does not know if this is a “limited outbreak” and he omits the recent and relevant results in a paper co-published by DFO (attached) that reports that VHS can infect Atlantic salmon and “spillback” into wild populations causing 100% mortality in herring in 3/4 trials.
Given that these herring were observed in an area surrounded by Atlantic salmon farms to the south, east and north, it is my opinion that Dr. Marty should have added comment regarding this high relevant and alarming finding by DFO. The CFIA reports there are salmon farms infected with VHS http://www.inspection.gc.ca/animals/aquatic-animals/diseases/reportable/2013/eng/1360390270607/1360390361782
“3.3. Experiment 3: transmission of VHSV from Atlantic salmon to herring
Transmission of VHSV from Atlantic salmon to sympatric Pacific herring was indicated by 100% mortality and recovery of VHSV with titers exceeding 1 ???? 106 from herring sentinels in 3 out of 4 immersion replicates.”
This paper openly notes that: “herring biomass in salmon netpens can measure in the tons in some salmon farms (unpublished observation, K. Garver)”
I am requesting that DFO and/or the province of BC follow up and correct Dr. Marty’s quote in the Globe and Mail. The governments of BC have the responsibility to inform the public accurately about a resource as valuable as herring. It is unethical in my view to suggest that herring bleeding throughout their bodies could be “actually good.” I would also like to know how the DFO and the Province of BC, who are responsible for the siting of each salmon farm, have responded to VHS in salmon farms and the recent DFO finding that this can potentially cause 100% mortality in BC herring.
Thank you.
Alexandra Morton
Comments
4 responses to “Dear BC Minister of Agriculture”
Dr.Marty is a registered veterinary.
The question regarding his comments are whether he used the level of care, skill and knowledge of a reasonably competent practitioner in his comments on the subject.
In his defence, he might have been misquoted so it might be prudent for Dr.Marty to issue a “setting it straight” – the normal practice when remarks are taken out of context. That is if he disagrees with the remarks attributed to him.
-30-
On checking, Dr. Marty is identified as a “resigned member” in the provincial list of veterinarians.
So why is a non-member speaking on veterinary matters for the provincial government?
Dear Alexandra,
I really appreciate all that you have taught me about the environment, particularly the horrors of interfering with natural cycles that is perpetrated by open feedlot aquaculture, and also your patient and lyrical work with orcas. Thankyou for sticking your neck out to save wild salmon.
It is of concern that I cannot find your facebook page this morning. Please get your voice back in this forum! Maybe a community page. I met a lady from olympic dolphins who has seen first hand the devastation in the seabed and similar feeding practices including the use of die in the last 2 weeks in Tasmanian farmed salmon.
Stay safe
Alexandra,
I’d like to suggest not just testing for disease, but also for radiation; even if the results are positive for disease, nuclear fall-out from the Fukushima disaster could possibly be triggering this.
The disaster has been on-going for two and a half years now, and plenty of marine life is suddenly showing up dead or diseased; polar bears with oozing sores and hair loss, seals with bleeding lesions, sea turtle deaths, walrus deaths, etc etc. The list seems to go on and on.
Thanks for your time. Please consider this.